How To Prevent A Deficiency Judgment After A Short-Sale?
As horrible it is to lose your home to foreclosure, ex-homeowners may still be on the bait for the deficiency amount. This is simply the difference of what is owed on the mortgage and what the bank could sell at an auction. “Deficiency judgments” can haunt borrowers, years after they have lost their home.
It can be an unpleasant shock for borrowers who have sold their home via a short sale arrangement where the bank approved selling the property for an amount less than the mortgage debt.
Vanessa Corey who made a short-sale on her Fredericksburg, VA home in April of 2008 is a real life example. After building her house in 2004, unforeseen setbacks which led to a bitter divorce coupled with the economic housing crisis forced her to sell the house through a short-sale arrangement.
As a property agent, she assumed the lender had agreed to disregard the difference in amount owed after the short-sale. Late last year, her legal representative produced a letter from her lender with a demand to pay an owed amount of $65,000. As she didn’t have the money, she declared bankruptcy.
There are a lot of financial institutions who decline to discuss the topic of ‘deficiency judgments’. Correy’s financial institution who lent her the money stated that they were targeting more people with deficiencies.
How Do You Avoid A Deficiency Judgment? It depends on which state the homeowner resides in. Other things include if the borrower has a second mortgage or other liens. It can definitely hurt homeowners if they disregarded the issue altogether.
Real-estate attorney, Mr. Zaretsky mentioned that if your financial lender has achieved a judgment on the borrower, they can target you despite of your location. They have the power to ask for your financial records, hold your wages and put you in jail if you continued to turn away from their requests.
In reference to home foreclosures, lenders can pursue deficiency judgments in more than 30 states. According to the U.S. Foreclosure Network, an organization of mortgage firms, this includes states such as Florida, New York and Texas.
Fortunately in places like Arizona and California, they do not permit ‘deficiency judgments’. The other ten states that do not allow such judgments are Iowa, Alaska, North Dakota, Montana, Pennsylvania, Oregon, Washington, Wisconsin and South Carolina.
Although lenders are willing to forgive the deficiency amount, many borrowers are not aware that they are required to request for a release. To avoid any unforeseen surprises, ensure that your attorney requests the bank to release you of any future obligations.
Zaretsky says that homeowners should not take things for granted assuming that a deficiency judgment will not return and hit them. He believes that many of these judgments will be pursued over several years to come. It is important to note that these accounts were sold at a loss to various collection firms and third-party investors. These firms would not have purchased these loans if they weren’t eager in recovering the amount they paid for them.
Banks or collection firms do not act in obtaining judgments right away. As a strategy, they may act patient and allow debtors to financially improve prior to filing with the legal system. For example, banks have up to five years to file in Florida state. Once judgment is obtained, the bank has up to twenty years to pursue the debt with interest.
Financial institutions and debt collection companies can hunt down ex-homeowners in spite of a minor debt. In 2004, Mr. Varno and his spouse achieved a short-sale arrangement with their property after he was laid off from his job. In 2008, to his surprise, the second lien holder demanded 25 K from him. Mr. Varno explained that they had already released the title thus making him not indebted to the 2nd lien holder.
Disappointingly enough, that is far from the truth. Although the title was released, this will not make the debt vanish. As there are differences in state laws, a regular mortgage contract is split into 2 provisions. The first being the collateral exchange where the property is pledged. The 2nd is the contractual guarantee to pay off the loan.
Financial institutions may drop the liens to help allow a short-sale. This however does mean that they will terminate the original contractual agreement for the borrower to repay the loan as stated in the promissory notes. After selling the house, the secured debt can evolve into an unsecured debt.
Mr. Zaretsky explained an example about one of his customer who was so happy in achieving a short-sale that he foolishly signed all the documents his property agent gave him. Not knowing what was happening, he had also signed away a statement indicating that he is still owes and acknowledge the debt.
He was unaware that the financial institution could take that document and transform it into a deficiency judgment through the legal system.
Banks are not always on your side. Zaretsky mentioned of another customer who was wealthy enough to pay off the difference but the lender didn’t care as they had the power to target you for the debt in the foreseeable future.
Mr. Tolchinsky, a Florida state realtor claimed that financial institutions may pursue borrowers who walk-away if they suspect that they may have other listed assets.
Banks will research to see if it was a pure walking-away attempt where the borrower truly could not afford to make his or her mortgage payments. If they find out that the borrower has been making timely payments and is in financially sound status, he or she maybe targeted for the deficiency.
If you are unsure, it is recommendable to obtain the services of an attorney to make sure that the debt in the short-sale or deed-in-lieu agreement is negotiated away.
Receive free foreclosure prevention information by learning about the latest announcements on government programs such as HAMP and HAFA. Download the Free Podcast about Can My Lender Pursue A Deficiency Judgment From A Short Sale? for your own use, blog or website.